Beyond the Five Federal Indicators: What Workforce Boards Should Measure Next

Workforce board members reviewing printed scorecards and dashboard charts at a conference table

Local workforce board performance is now publicly visible, while states have more flexibility in how they operate their systems. Yet the accountability conversation has not fully caught up: federal measures show important participant outcomes, but they do not reveal whether a region’s education and workforce partners are improving the talent pipeline together. Boards can close that gap by choosing a small set of regional measures, connecting each to a decision, and reporting results with clarity.

Public performance data creates a strategic opportunity

The U.S. Department of Labor’s Employment and Training Administration now publishes WIOA performance results at the local workforce development board level. The Department announced the public transparency effort on August 13, 2025, and later posted board-level results. Its WIOA Local Workforce Development Board Performance Program Year 2024 release reports outcomes from July 1, 2024, through June 30, 2025, and includes a Registered Apprenticeship participation metric.

This visibility is an opportunity for boards to define their own performance story. A regional scorecard can help explain what federal results show, what they leave out, and how local partners are strengthening pathways to economic opportunity.

The policy direction reinforces the value of useful, transparent data. Executive Order 14278, “Preparing Americans for High-Paying Skilled Trade Jobs of the Future,” signed April 23, 2025, and published in the Federal Register on April 28, 2025 (90 FR 17525), directs federal agencies to improve transparency on workforce program and credential outcomes, including earnings and employment. It also calls for harmonizing measures and reducing reporting burden. The objective for regional leaders is not simply to collect more information. It is to make the information useful for action.

What the federal indicators do well, and what they cannot tell you

The five measures displayed in DOL’s local-board performance data are Employment Rate 2nd Quarter After Exit, Employment Rate 4th Quarter After Exit, Median Earnings 2nd Quarter After Exit, Credential Attainment, and Measurable Skill Gains. These indicators provide a common, comparable baseline. They are tied to established reporting requirements, and their public release makes board-level results easier to review alongside state and territory benchmarks.

One clarification matters: the five indicators displayed in the local-board data are not the entire WIOA primary indicator framework. WIOA also includes Effectiveness in Serving Employers, reported at the statewide level. The local-board dashboard adds Registered Apprenticeship participation as a separate metric.

These measures answer important questions about employment after exit, earnings at a point in time, credentials, and skill gains. The fourth-quarter employment rate does capture whether participants are working a year after exit, and the statewide Effectiveness in Serving Employers indicator tracks whether participants remain with the same employer from the second to the fourth quarter. Neither shows how earnings change for the same person over time, whether a credential connects to the region’s priority occupations, or whether colleges, workforce boards, employers, and other partners are coordinating effectively across an entire pathway.

That distinction is central to understanding why regional talent pipelines can break. Federal indicators offer a shared baseline. Regional measures can show whether the larger system is aligned and improving.

Four regional measures that connect outcomes to decisions

Additional measures should be selected to guide choices, not to expand reporting for its own sake. A focused regional scorecard could include the following.

1. Wage change for the same person

Track how earnings change for the same participant from before training to the second and fourth quarters after exit, and how many remain with the same employer between those quarters. The federal fourth-quarter employment rate shows whether people are working; this measure shows whether the work is paying more and holding. The decision it informs is whether training and support strategies are helping people enter and remain in work that offers a path to stronger earnings, and it can prompt partners to examine barriers during the transition into employment.

2. Completion and credential attainment across partners

Review completion and credential attainment across college and workforce partners together, using agreed definitions rather than treating each program as a separate result. This helps leaders identify where learners are progressing, where transitions between providers are difficult, and whether shared pathway design or support services need attention.

3. Talent pipeline fit with regional demand

Compare training capacity and completions with employer demand in priority industries or occupations. The decision this informs is whether partners should expand, adapt, coordinate, or reconsider programs and training capacity. A practical education-to-workforce alignment framework can help connect labor-market priorities to program and partnership decisions.

4. Return on investment and cost per outcome

Review the resources associated with outcomes such as completion, employment, and wage progression. This is a stewardship measure, not a cost-cutting exercise. It helps boards understand which investments are supporting shared goals, where resources may be better aligned, and what evidence is needed before a strategy is continued or expanded.

College and workforce staff comparing printed charts and data at a shared desk

These measures reflect a broader system view: regional workforce development and education-to-workforce alignment are related, but they answer different questions. Understanding how the two approaches work together can help boards distinguish program activity from region-wide pipeline outcomes.

Keep the scorecard small and decision-focused

A useful board scorecard does not need to measure every activity. It needs to help leaders make a few consequential decisions consistently.

For each measure, boards should:

  • Tie it to a decision. State what the measure will help leaders continue, change, align, or resource.
  • Name an owner. Assign responsibility for producing and interpreting the measure, with partner roles clear where data crosses organizations.
  • Set a review cadence. Choose a regular schedule that gives leaders time to act on findings rather than simply receive reports.
  • Publish the same numbers internally and externally. Consistent reporting supports trust and makes it easier to explain both progress and areas for improvement.

State flexibility can support this work without displacing federal accountability. In its September 2, 2026 report, Jobs for the Future, From Flexibility to Action: What States’ WIOA Waiver Requests Tell Us About the Future of Workforce Reform, reviewed waiver response letters for 40 states and territories under the Program Year 2026–2027 state plan modifications. JFF reported that DOL did not approve requests to reduce federally required reporting or alter core performance requirements. It also noted that states already have authority to add measures such as median wage gains, retention, and return on investment. A waiver is not required to measure more.

Oregon’s Workforce and Talent Development Board offers a practical example of measures connected to shared priorities. Its 2026–2028 Strategic Plan and Scorecard organizes work around shared workforce goals, including closing skills gaps in priority industry sectors, holding WorkSource Oregon partners accountable to performance measures, and influencing youth and student outcomes. The value is in connecting the goals to partner action and ongoing review.

Make governance and data-sharing part of the measurement strategy

A scorecard is only as reliable as the relationships and definitions behind it. Colleges, workforce boards, employers, and other partners need shared definitions for outcomes such as completion, credential attainment, retention, and wage gain. They also need data-sharing agreements that clarify how records will be accessed, protected, combined, and used.

The board can reinforce this foundation by organizing agendas around a small scorecard. Partners should have a regular opportunity to review the same information, interpret what it means, identify gaps, and agree on next steps. A regional governance measure can track whether partners are sharing agreed-upon records and reviewing them together. That makes data alignment part of system performance, not a technical task set aside from strategy.

Legislative developments also make deliberate measurement design timely. A Stronger Workforce for America Act of 2026 was introduced in the U.S. House on April 6, 2026, and ordered reported by the Committee on Education and the Workforce on April 21, 2026, by a vote of 19 to 14. It is proposed legislation, not law: it has not been considered on the House floor and has no Senate companion, so its path remains uncertain. In its April 15, 2026 policy alert, the National Association of Workforce Boards described the bill as having a more elaborate performance accountability section with greater data and reporting requirements for local boards and eligible training providers. Regional leaders can strengthen readiness by developing measures that support decisions now, while remaining attentive to any future federal requirements.

Define performance through shared progress

Public federal results provide a common starting point. Regional measures can extend the picture to retention, pathway completion, demand alignment, and stewardship. When those measures are deliberately chosen, consistently defined, and connected to board decisions, accountability becomes more than reporting. It becomes a practical tool for coordinated improvement.

Morse Strategies partners with workforce boards, educational institutions, state leaders, and economic development organizations on measurement design, board scorecards, and cross-system data alignment. Contact Morse Strategies to discuss how your region can strengthen its performance framework and turn shared priorities into measurable progress.

Sources